Volume 10 Number 1 Spring 2014
Editor
Stephanie Anne Shelton http://jolle.coe.uga.edu
Students with Learning Disabilities in an Inclusive Writing Classroom
Jacobs, Patricia, patrjac@ufl.edu
University of Florida, Florida, USA
Fu, Danling, danlingfu@coe.ufl.edu
University of Florida, Florida, USA
Abstract
This article presents a case study on two fourth grade students with learning disabilities in two different writing situations: writing for test preparation and writing for digital stories. The students. writing behaviors, processes, and products in these two settings are contrasted. The differences in the students. writing experiences suggest that classroom teachers need to transform our teaching of writing by drawing on students. home literacies to ignite their passion and creativity. The research findings demonstrate that a test-driven teaching approach tends to limit students. ability as learners. Also, in contrast, instruction that values students. technological expertise energizes students. learning, helps them to reach their potential, and ensures their school success. The article concludes by advocating for change in classroom teachers teaching methods and curriculum by inviting students. home literacies into school, valuing their interests, and preparing them to be literate citizens for the 21st century.
Key words: learning disabilities, writing, digital literacies, home literacies
Please cite this article as: Jacobs, P., & Fu, D. (2014). Students with learning disabilities in an inclusive writing classroom. Journal of Language and Literacy Education [Online], 10(1), 100-113. Retrieved from http://jolle.coe.uga.edu.
Jacobs, P., & Fu, D. / Learning Disabilities (2014) 101
Writing is difficult for many students, and poses special challenges for students with learning disabilities (Harris, Graham, & Mason, 2006). These students have historically been disadvantaged (Berry, 2006; McPhail & Freeman, 2005) through education in classroom settings away from most peers their age. In resource rooms, teachers group students diagnosed with learning disabilities (LD), where they often work on isolated skills and do not gain a broader picture of the complexities of writing (Graham, Harris, Fink-Chorzempa, & MacArthur, 2003). Year by year, these students continue to fall behind their peers in regular classrooms (Van Kraayenoord, Miller, Moni, & Jobling, 2009). Teachers, researchers, and parents have challenged this kind of homogeneous grouping practice because students with LD are separated from mainstream education, limiting interaction with their mainstream peers and often receiving inferior instruction. Research has indicated that students with LD benefit from learning in an environment that engages them in peer-interaction and authentic literacy learning activities (Graham & Perrin, 2007).
In order to provide students with LD equal learning opportunities and an effective learning environment, several researchers have recommended an inclusive model (Cole, Waldron, Majd, & Hasazi, 2004; McLeskey & Waldron, 2000) since the late 1990s. The inclusive model aims to educate as many students with disabilities as possible in regular classroom settings while still meeting their unique needs based on the least restrictive environment (LRE) provision of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA, 2004). LRE means that, to the maximum extent possible, school districts must educate students with disabilities in regular education classrooms and provide them with appropriate support such as curriculum modification, an itinerant teacher with special education training, or computer-assisted devices as examples. IDEA requires that school districts have a continuum of placements and services available to accommodate the needs of all children with disabilities ranging from care facilities to regular classroom settings with support services. The students. needs as determined by the Individual Education Program (IEP) and each individual student.s IEP team drive the degree of inclusion. It is important to point out that the inclusive model alone does not guarantee academic gains; however, students with mild LD who are educated along with their peers in an integrated educational setting have been found to benefit academically, socially, and emotionally (Ferretti, MacArthur, & Okolo, 2001; Waldron & McLeskey,1998).
Many students with LD face greater challenges than their education peers without LD when learning how to write. Writing is a complex process that requires the integration of many cognitive and social processes and comprehensive language skills. Students with learning difficulties struggle with generating topics, planning and organizing, editing, revising, monitoring the writing process, and transcribing words (Patel & Laud, 2007; Troia, 2006). They have fewer strategies with writing, less knowledge about writing, and behavior and motivational factors that impede success as school writers (MacArthur,
Volume 10 Number 1 Spring 2014EditorStephanie Anne Shelton http://jolle.coe.uga.eduStudents with Learning Disabilities in an Inclusive Writing ClassroomJacobs, Patricia, patrjac@ufl.eduUniversity of Florida, Florida, USAFu, Danling, danlingfu@coe.ufl.eduUniversity of Florida, Florida, USAAbstractThis article presents a case study on two fourth grade students with learning disabilities in two different writing situations: writing for test preparation and writing for digital stories. The students. writing behaviors, processes, and products in these two settings are contrasted. The differences in the students. writing experiences suggest that classroom teachers need to transform our teaching of writing by drawing on students. home literacies to ignite their passion and creativity. The research findings demonstrate that a test-driven teaching approach tends to limit students. ability as learners. Also, in contrast, instruction that values students. technological expertise energizes students. learning, helps them to reach their potential, and ensures their school success. The article concludes by advocating for change in classroom teachers teaching methods and curriculum by inviting students. home literacies into school, valuing their interests, and preparing them to be literate citizens for the 21st century.Key words: learning disabilities, writing, digital literacies, home literaciesPlease cite this article as: Jacobs, P., & Fu, D. (2014). Students with learning disabilities in an inclusive writing classroom. Journal of Language and Literacy Education [Online], 10(1), 100-113. Retrieved from http://jolle.coe.uga.edu.Jacobs, P., & Fu, D. / Learning Disabilities (2014) 101Writing is difficult for many students, and poses special challenges for students with learning disabilities (Harris, Graham, & Mason, 2006). These students have historically been disadvantaged (Berry, 2006; McPhail & Freeman, 2005) through education in classroom settings away from most peers their age. In resource rooms, teachers group students diagnosed with learning disabilities (LD), where they often work on isolated skills and do not gain a broader picture of the complexities of writing (Graham, Harris, Fink-Chorzempa, & MacArthur, 2003). Year by year, these students continue to fall behind their peers in regular classrooms (Van Kraayenoord, Miller, Moni, & Jobling, 2009). Teachers, researchers, and parents have challenged this kind of homogeneous grouping practice because students with LD are separated from mainstream education, limiting interaction with their mainstream peers and often receiving inferior instruction. Research has indicated that students with LD benefit from learning in an environment that engages them in peer-interaction and authentic literacy learning activities (Graham & Perrin, 2007).In order to provide students with LD equal learning opportunities and an effective learning environment, several researchers have recommended an inclusive model (Cole, Waldron, Majd, & Hasazi, 2004; McLeskey & Waldron, 2000) since the late 1990s. The inclusive model aims to educate as many students with disabilities as possible in regular classroom settings while still meeting their unique needs based on the least restrictive environment (LRE) provision of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA, 2004). LRE means that, to the maximum extent possible, school districts must educate students with disabilities in regular education classrooms and provide them with appropriate support such as curriculum modification, an itinerant teacher with special education training, or computer-assisted devices as examples. IDEA requires that school districts have a continuum of placements and services available to accommodate the needs of all children with disabilities ranging from care facilities to regular classroom settings with support services. The students. needs as determined by the Individual Education Program (IEP) and each individual student.s IEP team drive the degree of inclusion. It is important to point out that the inclusive model alone does not guarantee academic gains; however, students with mild LD who are educated along with their peers in an integrated educational setting have been found to benefit academically, socially, and emotionally (Ferretti, MacArthur, & Okolo, 2001; Waldron & McLeskey,1998).Many students with LD face greater challenges than their education peers without LD when learning how to write. Writing is a complex process that requires the integration of many cognitive and social processes and comprehensive language skills. Students with learning difficulties struggle with generating topics, planning and organizing, editing, revising, monitoring the writing process, and transcribing words (Patel & Laud, 2007; Troia, 2006). They have fewer strategies with writing, less knowledge about writing, and behavior and motivational factors that impede success as school writers (MacArthur,
การแปล กรุณารอสักครู่..
